Metal Roof vs. Shingles – Which Is Right for You
January 19, 2021
You want more than just a place to live when it comes to building a house. A safe and secure place is exactly what you need. Proper roofing can help create this security. The roof’s functions make it a very important material when it comes to building constructions. A roof should fit well with the building’s structure, and protect you from external elements like harsh weather. When it is time to put up a new roof, the variety of options available can overwhelm you. For a while now, shingles have been the most common choice of roofing materials for homes. They are cost-effective, easy to maintain, and available in a variety of textures and colors. The modern fiberglass core gives the shingle its durability, and the presence of granules helps protect it from harsh climate conditions and ultraviolet rays. However, metal roofs have started gaining more popularity recently. They are made of corrugated tin panels and suit refined and less rustic building structures. They are lightweight, energy-efficient, and durable as well. Their designs come in a large variety too, which makes them very appealing as well.
Both shingles and metal roofing are good options for residential homes. They both offer protection to your home and should ideally last long. Depending on your preference, one or the other should be more suited to your need. You have to choose the one that is right for your needs. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages. To help you make the right decision, we have made comparisons of these two materials under the following headings:
Depending on the coating applied and the metal used, metal roofing is very versatile. It comes in a variety of styles. Aluminum is one material that does not need a coating, unlike steel. Steel needs special treatment to prevent it from rusting. Stainless steel, zinc, titanium, and copper are other metals used for roofing.
Shingles on the other hand come in two varieties, the organic ones and the more novel fiberglass shingles. The layered make-up of synthetic shingles is the only difference between them. The fiberglass shingles have a core made with fiberglass, enveloped with an asphalt layer, while the organic ones have a heavy felt layer covered with the asphalt.
The standard metal roof is made from standing-seam metal used for industrial buildings. The corrugated tin panel does not limit its application. This makes it very useful. It is made from galvanized metal, copper, zinc, and aluminum. These are all materials that come in a wide range of colors and styles. A metal roof can even be made to look like shingle roofs.
People find the traditional shingle more attractive because of its simple aesthetics. However, to imitate other roofing products, it is now produced in a range of styles. Shingles can realistically simulate tile, wood shakes, and slate. It can also be shaped into various styles with scalloped edges and curves. Its color option is massive. This suggests that it can be matched or contrasted with the paint, bricks, or roofing of any nearby home. Its options vary from highly polished ones to weathered-looking ones.
Metal roofing offers more sustainability as it is produced from recycled material. It is helpful especially in hot weather since they help reflect the sun’s heat. It is even more reflective if the surface is painted. This reflective property makes it more energy-efficient. This has both financial and environmental benefits.
Shingles are a petroleum-based product. It is less environmentally friendly because it is a non-renewable fossil fuel. It is not long-lasting when compared with metal roofs. As a result, replacement and repairs are more frequent. However, its insulating properties are very good. This helps to cut down on energy bills
The metal roof is about three times the cost of shingles, but you will get a lot more life out of it. However, you can save money in the long run because of its energy efficiency. You do not have to spend more money on replacements and repairs either.
Shingles are less expensive when compared with metal roofing. The cost of its materials and installation is cheaper. However, the downside to their low-cost is that they have a shorter lifespan. During the entire lifetime of a metal roof, shingles might need to be replaced two or three times. Energy Efficiency
Due to the reflective surface of the metal roof, the transfer of heat into the home is lessened during summers. This makes it more energy efficient. Besides, energy-saving equipment such as solar panels can be mounted on metal roofs using clamps.
Shingles, on the other hand, absorb more heat. This transfer of heat into the home makes the cooling system work harder. Though, it performs better in winters. It makes the home warmer by using the heat absorbed from the winter’s sunlight. This makes them more suited to a temperate climate.
The metal roof is highly long-lasting. It is impervious to the damage caused by the weather. In other words, weather conditions have little effect on it. Its exterior is not very porous, so moisture cannot cause damage. However, the falling of large hailstorms or tree branches on it may cause it to dent.
Shingles are susceptible to crack, corrosion, and wear caused by weather conditions such as heat, rain, and hail. Because of its porous exterior, the growth of algae and fungus on it can make it look weathered and less attractive.
Maintenance and Repair
A skilled tradesman is required for the installation of metal roofs. The work leaves no room for error and requires precision. Because of its durability, it requires almost no maintenance if installed properly. Because of its lightweight, its life span may also be extended.
Generally, shingles are easier to install and repair. Though, it is more prone to damage. Because of this, it may require regular inspection and repairs. Depending on the size of the house, its installation should take about a day or two. Just like the installation of metal roofs, a specialized tradesman is required for shingles as well.
The metal roof is non-combustible and is rated Class A for fire safety. It is a good choice, especially in areas prone to wildfires. It is less likely to be affected by fire if embers fall on it, unlike shingle roofing.
The difference between both types of roofing should be clear to you. Nevertheless, you still need to figure out the best option for you. Metal roofing is the best choice if you are looking at increased resistance to harsh weather, durability, energy efficiency, longevity, and high resale value. Shingles, on the other hand, are best suited if your primary concerns are low costs and a more traditional appeal. In your context, consider their benefits, and take into account both long-term and short-term issues. Whichever one you prefer, it is also worth discussing your choice with roofing professionals.